(Non-)Moderating the Migration and Mobility of EU Citizens: A Literature Review

• Autorzy: Jenny Kunhardt
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

This article presents a systematic literature review of 84 English-language publications which analysed findings concerning how institutions addressed and moderated different patterns and challenges of migration and mobility within the European right of free movement zone. The synopsis of the publications shows the ignorance of many institutions towards migrating and mobile EU citizens, due to conflicts of interest and the dismissal of responsibilities. The lack of coordination between political levels and the missing implementation of equal rights have exclusionary effects for vulnerable groups and show ambivalences of the European integration process.(original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

PL

Migracja; Mobilność ludności; Migracja ludności; Obywatelstwo UE; Recenzja

EN

Migration; Population mobility; Population migration; Citizenship of the European Union; Review

• Czasopismo: Central and Eastern European Migration Review
• Rocznik: 2023
• Tom: 12
• Numer: nr 2
• Strony: 207-225

Twórcy

autor

Jenny Kunhardt

• University of Applied Sciences Erfurt

Bibliografia

• Amelina A., Carmel E., Runfors A., Scheibelhofer E. (eds) (2021). Boundaries of European Social Citizenship. EU Citizens' Transnational Social Security in Regulations, Discourses and Experiences. London: Routledge.
• Arnholtz J., Lillie N. (eds) (2021). Posted Work in the European Union. The Political Economy of Free Movement. London: Routledge.
• Balaban D.C., Huţuleac V. (2021). Public Measures to Deal with the Negative Effects of Intra-EU Migration. Case Study: Suceava County, Romania. Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences 62E: 5-21.
• Balch A., Balabanova E., Trandafoiu R. (2014). A Europe of Rights and Values? Public Debates on Sarkozy's Roma Affair in France, Bulgaria and Romania. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 40(8): 1154-1174.
• Barbulescu R., Favell A. (2020). Commentary: A Citizenship without Social Rights? EU Freedom of Movement and Changing Access to Welfare Rights. International Migration 58(1): 151-165.
• Barnard C., Fraser Butlin S. (2020). The Rule of Law and Access to the Courts for EU Migrants. Journal of Common Market Studies 58(6): 1621-1634.
• Bermudez A., Brey E. (2017). Is Spain Becoming a Country of Emigration Again? Data Evidence and Public Responses, in: J.-M. Lafleur, M. Stanek (eds), South-North Migration of EU Citizens in Times of Crisis, pp. 83-98. Cham: Springer VS, IMISCOE Research Series.
• Blauberger M., Schmidt S.K. (2014). Welfare Migration? Free Movement of EU Citizens and Access to Social Benefits. Research & Politics 1(3): 1-7.
• Bouali C. (2018). Facing Precarious Rights and Resisting EU 'Migration Management': South European Migrant Struggles in Berlin. Social Inclusion 6(1): 166-175.
• Bousiou A., Bucken-Knapp G., Spehar A. (2016). Local Welcoming Policies for EU Migrants: Consolidated Report. Gothenburg: University of Gothenburg.
• Bruzelius C. (2019). Freedom of Movement, Social Rights and Residence-Based Conditionality in the European Union. Journal of European Social Policy 29(1): 70-83.
• Bruzelius C. (2020). Local Government Responses to EU Citizens' Integration Needs. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 48(9): 2187-2205.
• Bruzelius C., Seeleib-Kaiser M. (2023). Enforcing Outsiders' Rights: Seasonal Agricultural Workers and Institutionalised Exploitation in the EU. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 49(16): 4188-4205.
• Bruzelius C., Chase E., Seeleib-Kaiser M. (2016). Social Rights of EU Migrant Citizens: Britain and Germany Compared. Social Policy and Society 15(3): 403-416.
• Bucken-Knapp G., Hinnfors J., Spehar A., Zelano K. (2018). The Multi-Level Governance of Intra EU Movement, in: P. Scholten, M. van Ostaijen (eds), Between Mobility and Migration: The Multi-Level Governance of Intra-European Movement, pp. 125-140. Cham: Springer Nature.
• Calzada I., Páez V., Martínez-Cassinello R., Hervás A. (2023). The Best Welfare Deal: Retirement Migrants as Welfare Maximizer. Societies 13(4): 102.
• Cancedda A., Curtarelli M., Hoorens S., Viertelhauzen T., Hofman J. (2015). Socio-Economic Inclusion of Migrant EU Workers in 4 Cities: Synthesis Report. Brussels: European Commision.
• Carmel E., Sojka B. (2021). Beyond Welfare Chauvinism and Deservingness. Rationales of Belonging as a Conceptual Framework for the Politics and Governance of Migrants' Rights. Journal of Social Policy 50(3): 645-667.
• Ciornei I. (2016). European Mobility and Local Political Incorporation: The Case of British and Romanian Residents in Spain. Migration Studies 4(1): 38-58.
• Croitoru A. (2021). Diaspora Start-Up Programs and Creative Industries. Evidence from Romania. Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences 63E: 5-29.
• Dølvik J.E., Eldring L. (eds) (2017). Labour Mobility in the Enlarged Single European Market. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing.
• Dølvik J.E., Marginson P., Alsos, K., Arnholtz J., Meardi G., Müller T., Trygstad S. (2018). Collective Wage Regulation in Northern Europe under Strain: Multiple Drivers of Change and Differing Responses. European Journal of Industrial Relations 24(4): 321-339.
• Dølvik J.E., Visser J. (2009). Free Movement, Equal Treatment and Workers' Rights: Can the European Union Solve its Trilemma of Fundamental Principles? Industrial Relations Journal 40(6): 491-509.
• Dwyer P.J., Scullion L., Jones K., Stewart A. (2019). The Impact of Conditionality on the Welfare Rights of EU Migrants in the UK. Policy & Politics 47(1): 133-150.
• Eigmüller M. (2013). Europeanization from Below: The Influence of Individual Actors on the EU Integration of Social Policies. Journal of European Social Policy 23(4): 363-375.
• Engbersen G., Leerkes A., Scholten P., Snel E. (2017). The Intra-EU Mobility Regime: Differentiation, Stratification and Contradictions. Migration Studies 5(3): 337-355.
• Eremenko T., El Qadim N., Steichen E. (2017). Southern Europeans in France: Invisible Migrants? In: J.-M. Lafleur, M. Stanek (eds), South-North Migration of EU Citizens in Times of Crisis, pp. 123-148. Cham: Springer VS, IMISCOE Research Series.
• Eurofound (2015). Social Dimension of Intra-EU Mobility: Impact on Public Services. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
• EY (2014). Evaluation of the Impact of the Free Movement of EU Citizen at Local Level: Final Report. http://europa.formez.it/sites/all/files/evaluation_free_mov_final_report.pdf (accessed 21 May 2021).
• Friberg J.H., Eldring L. (2013). Labour Migrants from Central and Eastern Europe in the Nordic Countries. Patterns of Migration, Working Conditions and Recruitment Practices. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers.
• Fries-Tersch E., Jones M., Siöland L. (2021). Annual Report on Intra-EU Labour Mobility 2020. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
• Genelyte I. (2017). Policy Response to Emigration from the Baltics: Confronting 'The European Elephant in the Room', in: J.E. Dølvik, L. Eldring (eds), Labour Mobility in the Enlarged Single European Market, pp. 45-72. Bingley: Emerald Group.
• Grabbe C. (2023). Free Movement and Access to Social Security in the EU: The Challenge of Exporting Unemployment Benefits. European Journal of Social Security 25(1): 20-40.
• Heimann C. (2021). Blessing and Curse of Intra-EU Mobility: Free Labour Movement in Spain, Germany and the UK. Wiesbaden: Springer VS.
• Heimann C., Wieczorek O. (2017). The Role of Argumentation and Institutions for Labour Migration in the European Union - Exemplified by Spanish Labour Migration to Germany. International Migration 55(S1): 69-85.
• Heindlmaier A., Blauberger M. (2017). Enter at your Own Risk: Free Movement of EU Citizens in Practice. West European Politics 40(6): 1198-1217.
• Hodgson G. (2006). What Are Institutions? Journal of Economic Issues 40(1): 1-25.
• Johns M. (2014). The New Minorities of Europe: Social Cohesion in the European Union. Lanham, Md: Lexington Books.
• Kindler M. (2018). Poland's Perspective on the Intra-European Movement of Poles. Implications and Governance Responses, in: P. Scholten, M. van Ostaijen (eds), Between Mobility and Migration: The Multi-Level Governance of Intra-European Movement, pp. 183-204. Cham: Springer Nature.
• Kirch A. (2018). 'Knowledge Workers' in the Baltic Sea Region: Comparative Assessment of Innovative Performance of the Countries in the Macro-Region. Baltic Journal of European Studies 8(1): 176-196.
• Kostka J. (2018). No Country for Poor People: The Case Study of the Romanian Roma Migrants in Poland. Intersections - East European Journal of Society and Politics 4(2): 169-188.
• Kovacs R., Girasek E., Kovacs E., Aszalos Z., Eke E., Ragany K., Cserhati Z., Szocska M. (2017). Managing Intra-EU Mobility - Do WHO Principles of Ethical Recruitment Have Relevance? Human Ressources for Health 15(78): 1-8.
• Kramer D., Sampson Thierry J., van Hooren F. (2018). Responding to Free Movement: Quarantining Mobile Union Citizens in European Welfare States. Journal of European Public Policy 25(10): 1501-1521.
• Lafleur J.-M., Mescoli E. (2018). Creating Undocumented EU Migrants through Welfare: A Conceptualization of Undeserving and Precarious Citizenship. Sociology 52(3): 480-496.
• Lafleur J.-M., Stanek M. (2017a). Restrictions on Access to Social Protection by New Southern European Migrants in Belgium, in: J.-M. Lafleur, M. Stanek (eds), South-North Migration of EU Citizens in Times of Crisis, pp. 99-121. Cham: Springer VS, IMISCOE Research Series.
• Lafleur J.-M., Stanek M. (eds) (2017b). South-North Migration of EU Citizens in Times of Crisis. Cham: Springer VS, IMISCOE Research Series.
• Magazzini T., Chiozza E., Rossi M. (2019). Inclusion Policies? Missed Opportunities at the European and Local Levels, in: T. Magazzini, S. Piemontese (eds), Constructing Roma Migrants: European Narratives and Local Governance, pp. 51-67. Cham: Springer VS.
• Magazzini T., Piemontese S. (eds) (2019). Constructing Roma Migrants: European Narratives and Local Governance. Cham: Springer VS, IMISCOE Research Series.
• Manca M., Vergnano C. (2019). When Housing Policies Are Ethnically Targeted: Struggles, Conflicts and Contentions for a 'Possible City', in: T. Magazzini, S. Piemontese (eds), Constructing Roma Migrants: European Narratives and Local Governance, pp. 91-109. Cham: Springer VS.
• Mantu S., Minderhoud P. (2019). Exploring the Links between Residence and Social Rights for Economically Inactive EU Citizens. European Journal of Migration and Law 21(3): 313-337.
• Mantu S., Minderhoud P. (2023). Struggles over Social Rights: Restricting Access to Social Assistance for EU Citizens. European Journal of Social Security 25(1): 3-19.
• Mantu S., Minderhoud P., Grütters C. (2021). Legal Approaches to 'Unwanted' EU Citizens in the Netherlands. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 10(1): 35-53.
• Marchand K., Fajth V., Siegel M. (2019). Relevant Data to Understand Migration in the EU. Main Report. Maastricht: Maastricht University.
• Martinsen D.S., Werner B. (2019). No Welfare Magnets - Free Movement and Cross-Border Welfare in Germany and Denmark Compared. Journal of European Public Policy 26(5): 637-655.
• McMahon S. (2013). Negotiating Meanings and Power: The Politics of Romanian Immigration in Italy and Spain. London: King's College London, PhD thesis.
• Minas R., Enroth N. (2015). Vulnerable EU Citizens: Local Solutions and Strategies in European Cities. Stockholm: Stockholm University, Department of Social Work, Working Paper Series 1.
• Mostowska M. (2011). Services of Homeless Immigrants: The Social Welfare Capital of Polish Rough Sleepers in Brussels and Oslo. European Journal of Homelessness 5(1): 27-47.
• Mostowska M. (2014). 'We Shouldn't But We Do ...': Framing the Strategies for Helping Homeless EU Migrants in Copenhagen and Dublin. British Journal of Social Work 44 (S1): i18-i34.
• Mullan J. (2017). Freedom of Movement at a Crossroads: Welfare Governance and the Boundaries of Belonging in the European Union. Politiche Sociali 3: 447-468.
• Parker O., López Catalán Ó. (2014). Free Movement for Whom, Where, When? Roma EU Citizens in France and Spain. International Political Sociology 8(4): 379-395.
• Persdotter M. (2019). Free to Move Along: On the Urbanisation of Cross-Border Mobility Controls - A Case of Roma 'EU Migrants' in Malmö, Sweden. Malmö: University of Malmö, PhD thesis.
• Piemontese S., Plainer Z., Bianconi L., Stefanova D., Förschner M. (2013). 'Roma Migrants' in Five European Countries. Policy Contexts and National Integration Strategies. REdHNET Report 2.
• Raithelhuber E. (2019). The Stilled-Other of the Citizen. 'Roma Beggars' and Regimes of (Im)mobility in an Austrian City, in: T. Magazzini, S. Piemontese (eds), Constructing Roma Migrants: European Narratives and Local Governance, pp. 129-154. Cham: Springer VS.
• Ratzmann N. (2021). Deserving of Social Support? Street-Level Bureaucrats' Decisions on EU Migrants' Benefit Claims in Germany. Social Policy and Society 20(3): 509-520.
• Ratzmann N. (2022). 'No German, No Service': EU Migrants' Unequal Access to Welfare Entitlements in Germany. Social Inclusion 10(1): 227-238.
• Refslund B. (2016). Intra-European Labour Migration and Deteriorating Employment Relations in Danish Cleaning and Agriculture: Industrial Relations under Pressure from EU8/2 Labour Inflows? Economic and Industrial Democracy 37(4): 597-621.
• Refslund B. (2021). When Strong Unions Meet Precarious Migrants: Building Trustful Relations to Unionise Labour Migrants in a High Union-Density Setting. Economic and Industrial Democracy 42(2): 314-335.
• Roos C. (2019). The (De-)Politicization of EU Freedom of Movement: Political Parties, Opportunities, and Policy Framing in Germany and the UK. Comparative European Politics 17(5): 631-650.
• Roos C., Westerveen L. (2020). The Conditionality of EU Freedom of Movement: Normative Change in the Discourse of EU Institutions. Journal of European Social Policy 30(1): 63-78.
• Scheibelhofer E. (2022). Migrants' Experiences with Limited Access to Social Protection in a Framework of EU Post-National Policies. Social Inclusion 10(1): 164-173.
• Schmidt V.A. (2008). Discursive Institutionalism: The Explanatory Power of Ideas and Discourse. Annual Review of Political Science 11(1): 303-326.
• Scholten P. (2018). Beyond Migrant Integration Policies: Rethinking the Urban Governance of Migration-Related Diversity. Croatian and Comparative Administration 18(1): 7-30.
• Scholten P., van Ostaijen M. (eds) (2018). Between Mobility and Migration: The Multi-Level Governance of Intra-European Movement. Cham: Springer Nature.
• Scholten P., Engbersen G., van Ostaijen M., Snel E. (2018). Multilevel Governance from Below: How Dutch Cities Respond to Intra-EU Mobility'. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 44(12): 2011-2033.
• Shaw J., Miller N. (2012). When Legal Worlds Collide: An Exploration of What Happens When EU Free Movement Law Meets UK Immigration Law. Edinburgh: Edinburgh School of Law Research Paper 2012/31, Europa Working Paper 2012/3.
• Simola A. (2018). Lost in Administration: (Re)Producing Precarious Citizenship for Young University-Educated Intra-EU Migrants in Brussels. Work, Employment and Society 32(3): 458-474.
• Soltész B. (2019). Youth Migration and Local Governance in the Danube Region: Challenges and Novel Approaches. Budapest: Hungarian Central Statistical Office, YOUMIG: Working Paper 4.
• Spehar A., Hinnfors J., Bucken-Knapp G. (2017). Passing the Buck: The Case of Failing Multilevel Governance and Vulnerable EU Migrants in Sweden. Nordic Journal of Migration Research 7(2): 114-123.
• Teichler U. (2009). Internationalisation of Higher Education: European Experiences. Asia Pacific Education Review 10(1): 93-106.
• Teichler U. (2019). Bologna and Student Mobility, A Fuzzy Relationship. Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research 32(4): 429-449.
• Tervonen M., Enache A. (2017). Coping with Everyday Bordering: Roma Migrants and Gatekeepers in Helsinki. Ethnic and Racial Studies 40(7): 1114-1131.
• Thelen K. (1999). Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Politics. Annual Review of Political Science 9(1): 369-404.
• Thierry J.S., Martinsen D.S. (2018). Lost in Translation: How Street-Level Bureaucrats Condition Union Solidarity. Journal of European Integration 40(6): 819-834.
• Thym D. (2015a). The Elusive Limits of Solidarity. Residence Rights of and Social Benefits for Economically Inactive Union Citizens. Common Market Law Review 52: 17-50.
• Thym D. (2015b). When Union Citizens Turn into Illegal Migrants: The Dano Case. European Law Review 40(2): 249-262.
• Ulceluse M., Bock B., Haartsen T. (2021). A Tale of Three Villages: Local Housing Policies, Well-Being and Encounters between Residents and Immigrants. Population, Space and Place 28(8): 1-11.
• Van Ostaijen M. (2017). Between Migration and Mobility Discourses: The Performative Potential within 'Intra-European Movement'. Critical Policy Studies 11(2): 166-190.
• Van Ostaijen M. (2020). Legitimating Intra-European Movement Discourses: Understanding Mobility and Migration. Comparative European Politics 18(1): 1-20.
• Van Ostaijen M., Scholten P. (2017). The Politics of Numbers. Framing Intra-EU Migrants in the Netherlands. Critical Policy Studies 11(4): 477-498.
• Van Ostaijen M., Scholten P. (2018). Conclusions and Reflection, in: P. Scholten, M. van Ostaijen (eds), Between Mobility and Migration: The Multi-Level Governance of Intra-European Movement, pp. 249-262. Cham: Springer Nature.
• Vermeersch P. (2013). The European Union and the Roma: An Analysis of Recent Institutional and Policy Developments. European Yearbook of Minority Issues 10(1): 341-358.
• Vrăbiescu I. (2019). Dwelling in Limbo. Temporality in the Governance of Romani Migrants in Spain, in: T. Magazzini, S. Piemontese (eds), Constructing Roma Migrants: European Narratives and Local Governance, pp. 109-128.Cham: Springer VS.
• Vrăbiescu I., Kalir B. (2018). Care-Full Failure: How Auxiliary Assistance to Poor Roma Migrant Women in Spain Compounds Marginalization. Social Identities 24(4): 520-532.
• Wagner B., Hassel A. (2017). Move to Work, Move to Stay? Mapping Atypical Labour Migration into Germany, in: J.E. Dølvik, L. Eldring (eds), Labour Mobility in the Enlarged Single European Market, pp. 125-158. Bingley: Emerald Group.
• Xiao Y., Watson M. (2019). Guidance on Conducting a Systematic Literature Review. Journal of Planning Education and Research 39(1): 93-112.
• Zelano K. (2018a). Balancing Informality and Need: Policy Responses to Informal East-West Migration in Austria, the Netherlands and Sweden. Policy Studies 39(5): 535-559.
• Zelano K. (2018b). Governance of the Free Movement of Workers and Persons at the European Level, in: P. Scholten, M. van Ostaijen (eds), Between Mobility and Migration: The Multi-Level Governance of Intra-European Movement, pp. 101-123. Cham: Springer Nature.
• Zelano K., Bucken-Knapp G., Hinnfors J., Spehar A. (2016). Urban Governance of CEE Mobility in European Urban Regions. Gothenburg: University of Gothenburg Department of Political Science, WP3 Comparative Report.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.54667/ceemr.2023.23