Integration Processes and Dual Citizenship

• Autorzy: Vytautas Sinkevičius
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

When relations of citizenship are regulated, it is very important to assess new actual situations, as well as the latest needs of society and the state and to react to them adequately. It is important that the Law on Citizenship defines which persons are citizens of the Republic of Lithuania, and in what situations a citizen of the Republic of Lithuania may be also a citizen of another state, since citizenship is not only a formal legal category, but it is also always inseparably related with the issues of sovereignty, national identity, political order, and the rights and freedoms of persons. While regulating the citizenship relations from the restoration of the State of Lithuania in 1918, the view was upheld that, as a rule, a citizen of Lithuania may not also be a citizen of another state at the same time, and that dual citizenship was allowed only in individual cases established in the law. The development of legislative regulation of citizenship after the 1992 Constitution entered into effect shows that legislation gradually widened the circle of persons who were allowed to be citizens of the Republic of Lithuania and of another state at the same time. In 2006, when a legal dispute arose regarding the compliance of some provisions of the Law on Citizenship with the Constitution, the Law on Citizenship used to contain the legal regulation whereby the absolute majority of citizens of the Republic of Lithuania, regardless of where they lived - in Lithuania or another foreign state - were allowed to be citizens of another state at the same time as well. By its ruling of 13 November 2006, the Constitutional Court recognised such legal regulation as being in conflict with the Constitution. If the legislator were really committed to following the provision that dual citizenship may be a widespread phenomenon - and this would be so if, alongside the cases specified in the draft Law on Citizenship, one would provide that also the persons who left Lithuania after 11 March 1990 are allowed to have dual citizenship-it would be necessary to correspondingly amend the provisions of Article 12 of the Constitution. This can be done by referendum only. No matter how the legislative regulation of the relations of citizenship of the Republic of Lithuania will be amended in the future, one must pay heed to the provisions of the Constitution, including those which entrench equality of rights of all persons and non-discrimination on grounds of ethnicity.

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Citizenship; Dual Citizenship; the Constitution; the Constitutional Court

• Wydawca: Sciendo
• Czasopismo: Baltic Journal of Law & Politics
• Rocznik: 2009
• Tom: 2
• Numer: 2
• Strony: 31-55

Daty

wydano

2009-01-01

online

2010-01-06

Twórcy

autor

Vytautas Sinkevičius

• Faculty of Law, Mykolas Romeris University, Lithuania

Bibliografia

• Birmontienė, Toma, et al. Lietuvos konstitucinė teisė (Lithuanian Constitutional Law). Vilnius: Lietuvos teisės universitetas, 2001.
• Dabartinės lietuvių kalbos žodynas (A Dictionary of Contemporary Lithuanian). Vilnius: Mokslo ir enciklopedijų leidykla, 1993.
• Lietuvos Respublikos Aukščiausiosios Tarybos ir Lietuvos Respublikos Aukščiausiosios Tarybos Prezidiumo dokumentų rinkinys (A Collection of Documents of the Supreme Council of the Republic of Lithuania and the Presidium of the Supreme Council of the Republic of Lithuania). T. 3. Vilnius: Valstybinis leidybos centras, 1991.
• Mikelėnienė, Dalia, and Valentinas Mikelėnas. Teismo procesas: teisės aiškinimo ir taikymo aspektai (Court Process: Aspects of Interpretation and Application of Law). Vilnius: Justitia, 1999.
• Ministrų Kabineto generalinio sekretoriaus 1937 m. sausio 29 d. raštas Nr. 65 (Note of the Secretary General of the Cabinet of Ministers as of the 29th of January, 1937, no. 65). LCVA, F. 1367, Ap. 9, B. 18. P. 95 (archival document).
• Narušienė, Regina. "Pilietybė ir naujas pilietybės įstatymo projektas (Citizenship and the New Draft Law on Citizenship)." Bernardinai 6th of April, 2009.
• "The Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania. A Concept Outline." Lietuvos aidas (the daily), 10th of May, 1991.
• The Draft of the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania. Official Gazette (Lietuvos Respublikos Aukščiausiosios Tarybos ir Vyriausybės žinios), 1992, no. 31-953.
• "The Resolution of the Supreme Council "On Announcing the Draft Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania for Public Debate." Lietuvos aidas (the daily), 1st of May, 1992.
• Treaty on Naturalisation and Military Service between the Republic of Lithuania and the United States of America. Official Gazette (Vyriausybės žinios), 1938, no. 623/4441.
• Law on Lithuanian Citizenship. Official Gazette (Vyriausybės žinios), 1939, no. 656/4811.
• Law on the Basics of National Security. Official Gazette, 1997, no. 2-16.
• The Draft Law on Citizenship of the Republic of Lithuania. Official Gazette, 2009, no. 19-747.
• On the 4 August 2005 petition of the Klaipėda Regional Court requesting to investigate whether Item 89 of the Instructions for Execution of Decisions as confirmed by Order No. 432 ‘On Confirming the Instructions for Execution of Decisions’ of 31 December 2002 issued by the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Lithuania is not in conflict with the Constitution of the Republic of Lithuania. Ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania (September 20, 2005).
• Šileikis, Egidijus. Alternatyvi konstitucinė teisė (Alternative Constitutional Law). Vilnius: Teisinės informacijos centras, 2003.
• "Teisininkas ir diplomatas sako radę konstitucinį dvigubos pilietybės išsaugojimo raktą (Lawyer and Diplomat Say They Found Key to Constitutional Preservation of Dual Citizenship)." BNS News Agency //
• Vaišvila, Alfonsas. "Dviguba pilietybė - ne tik dvigubos teisės (Dual Citizenship - Not Only Double Rights)." Jurisprudencija 7(109) (2008): 7-13.
• Vernickaitė, Aurelija. "Much Talk, Little Work." Verslo žinios (the daily), 9th of August, 2007.
• Vidaus reikalų ministerijos 1937 m. balandžio 15 d. aplinkraštis Nr. 50745 (Circular Note of the Ministry of the Internal Affairs as of the 15th of April, 1937, no. 5075). LCVA, F. 1367. Ap. 9, B. 295. P. 6 (archival document).
• Vidaus reikalų ministerijos Administracijos departamento 1939 m. balandžio 29 d. nutarimas Nr. 72105 (Decision of the Department of Administration of the Ministry of the Internal Affairs as of the 29th of April, 1939, no. 72105). LCVA, F. 1367, Ap. 9, B. 18. P. 32 (archival document).
• Vidaus reikalų ministerijos nuomonė dėl Alfonso Gerdvilo pilietybės (Opinion of the Ministry of the Internal Affairs on the Citizenship of Alfonsas Gerdvilas). LCVA, F. 1367, Ap. 9, B. 37. P. 126 (archival document).
• Vidaus reikalų ministerijos Piliečių apsaugos departamento 1926 m. rugsėjo 26 d. aplinkraštis Nr. 23238 (Circular Note of the Department of the Security of Citizens of the Ministry of Internal Affairs as of the 26th of September, 1926, no. 23238). LCVA, F. 1367, Ap. 9, B. 295. P. 10 (archival document).

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.2478/v10076-009-0010-z