Lower Flammability Limits : Experimental and Theoretical Determination Methods for Gaseous and Liquid Fuels. State of the Art

• Autorzy: Grabarczyk M. , Ciesińska W. , Porowski R.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.5604/01.3001.0009.5021

Warianty tytułu

PL

Eksperymentalne i obliczeniowe metody oznaczania dolnej granicy wybuchowości paliw gazowych i płynnych : przegląd stanu wiedzy

• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

This work is an in-depth discussion of the experimental methods of lower flammability limit (LFL) determination and estimation in gases and the vapours of liquids. The focus here includes the dependences and drawbacks of each method. The work also outlines past research and discoveries that relate to the determination of explosion limits.

PL

W publikacji szczegółowo omówiono eksperymentalne metody oznaczania oraz szacowania dolnej granicy wybuchowości gazów i par cieczy. Przedmiotem dyskusji są także zależności oraz niedostatki poszczególnych metod. Dodatkowo, w pracy przedstawiony został zarys historycznych odkryć i badań dotyczących określania granic wybuchowości.

Słowa kluczowe

EN

flammability limits; single component fuels

PL

granice wybuchowości; granica palności; paliwa jednoskładnikowe

• Wydawca: Wojskowa Akademia Techniczna im. Jarosława Dąbrowskiego
• Czasopismo: Problemy Mechatroniki : uzbrojenie, lotnictwo, inżynieria bezpieczeństwa
• Rocznik: 2016
• Tom: Vol. 7, Nr 4 (26)
• Strony: 85--114
• Opis fizyczny: Bibliogr. 104 poz.

Twórcy

autor

Grabarczyk M.

• Institute of Aviation, Engineering Design Center, 110/114 Krakowska Av., 02-256 Warsaw, Poland

autor

Ciesińska W.

• Warsaw University of Technology, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Mechanics and Petrochemistry (Plock), Institute of Chemistry, 17 Łukasiewicza Street, 09-400 Płock, Poland

autor

Porowski R.

• Main School of Fire Service, Faculty of Fire Safety Engineering, Construction Safety Department 52/54 Słowackiego Street, 01-629 Warsaw, Poland

Bibliografia

• [1] Lasota Wiktor. 2008. „Pożary w przemyśle naftowym – przebieg zdarzeń, przyczyny powstawania”. Bezpieczeństwo i Technika Pożarnicza 4: 157-168.
• [2] Asinger Friedrich. 1961. Wstęp do petrochemii. Warszawa: WNT.
• [3] Pofit-Szczepańska Melania. 2003. „Środowisko w niebezpieczeństwie – pożary paliw ropopochodnych”. Przegląd pożarniczy 10: 17-20.
• [4] Baubraskas Vytenis. 2003. Ignition Handbook: Principles and Applications to Fire Safety Engineering, Fire Investigation, Risk Management and Forensic Science. Issaquah WA. Fire Science Publications.
• [5] Spellman R. Frank. 2009. The Handbook of Safety Engineering: Principles and Applications. Government Institutes. Plymouth. USA.
• [6] von Humboldt Alexander, Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac. 1805. “Experiénce sur les moyens oediométriques et sur la proportion des principes constituants de l’atmosphére”. Journal of Physics 60: 11-45.
• [7] Britton G. Laurence. 2002. “Two hundred years of flammable limits”. Process Safety Progress 21: 1-11.
• [8] Mallard Ernest-François, Henri Louis Le Chatelier. 1881. “On the propagation velocity of burning in gaseous explosive mixture”. Comptes rendus de l’Académie des sciences 931: 5-48.
• [9] Jouguet Emilie. 1913. “Sur la propagation des deflagration dans les mélanges”. Comptes rendus de l’Académie des sciences 156.
• [10] Daniell P. 1930. The theory of flame motion. In Proceedings of the Royal Society A 126: 393-405.
• [11] Lewis Bernard, Guenther von Elbe. 1948. Theory of flame propagation. In Proceedings of the Symposium on Combustion 1-2: 183-188.
• [12] Zeldovich Yakov Borisovich, Grigory Isaakovich Barenblatt, V.B. Librovich, Georgy M. Makhviladze. 1985. Mathematical theory of combustion and explosion. New York. USA. Springer-Verlag New York Inc.
• [13] Coward H.F., G.W Jones. 1952 “Limits of flammability of gases and vapors”. Bulletin of Bureau of Mines 503.
• [14] Zabetakis Michael George. 1965. “Flammability characteristics of combustible gases and vapors”. Bulletin of Bureau of Mines 627.
• [15] Kuchta J.M. 1985. “Investigation of Fire and Explosion Accidents in the Chemical, Mining and Fuel-Related Industries – a Manual”. Bulletin of Bureau of Mines 680.
• [16] Coffee D. Robert, Philip Jr. C. Vogl, John J. Wheeler. 1972. “Flammability Characteristics of Methylene Chloride (Dichloromethane)”. Journal of Chemical and Engineering Data 17: 89-93.
• [17] Jarosiński Józef. 1986. „Granice palności gazów”. Prace Instytutu Lotnictwa, 3-4.
• [18] Grabarczyk Marcin, Rafał Porowski, Andrzej Teodorczyk. 2013. „Badanie granic wybuchowości par cieczy palnych w podwyższonych temperaturach”. Przemysł Chemiczny 92 (11): 2097-2099.
• [19] Grabarczyk Marcin, Rafał Porowski, Andrzej Teodorczyk. 2014. “Flammability characteristics of butanol fuel blends at various initial temperatures”. Archivum Combustions 34 (1): 49-69.
• [20] Rarata Grzegorz. 2008. Badania górnej granicy wybuchowości wodoru oraz gazowych homologów metanu w powietrzu i tlenie w warunkach podwyższonego ciśnienia i temperatury. Phd thesis. Warsaw University of Technology. Faculty of Power and Aeronautical Engineering. Warsaw. Poland.
• [21] PN-EN 1127-1:2011. Polish-European Standard. Explosive atmospheres. Explosion prevention and protection. Part 1: Basic concepts and methodology.
• [22] Spalding D.B. 1957. A theory of inflammability limit and flame quenching. In Proceedings of the Royal Society A240: 83-100.
• [23] De Smedt G., F. de Corte, R. Notele, J. Berghmans. 1999. “Comparison of two standard test methods for determining explosion limits of gases at atmospheric conditions”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 70 (3): 105-113
• [24] PN-EN 1839:2012-03. Polish-European Standard. Determination of explosion limits of gases and vapours.
• [25] Podstawka Tadeusz. 2014. Ocena ryzyka w miejscach pracy zagrożonych występowaniem atmosfer wybuchowych. Sandomierz: Wyd. Sannort.
• [26] Takahashi Akifumi, Urano Youkichi, Tokuhashi Kazuaki, Kondo Shigeo. 2003. “Effect of vessel size and shape on experimental flammability limits of gases”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 105 (1-3): 27-37.
• [27] Hilado C.J. 1975. “A method for estimating limits of flammability”. Journal of Fire and Flammability 6: 130-139.
• [28] Sheldon M. 1984. “A study of the flammability limits of gases and vapors”. Fire Prevention 174.
• [29] Cashdollar L. Kenneth, Martin Hertzberg. 1985. “20-L explosibility test chamber for dust and gases”. Review of Scientific Instruments 56 (4): 596-602.
• [30] Kondo Shigeo, Takahashi Akifumi, Takizawa Kenji, Tokuhashi Kazuaki. 2011. “On the pressure dependence of flammability limits of CH2=CFCF3, CH2F2 and methane”. Fire Safety Journal 46: 289-293.
• [31] Kondo Shigeo, Takahashi Akifumi, Takizawa Kenji, Tokuhashi Kazuaki. 2011. “On the temperature dependence of flammability limits of gases”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 187 (1-3): 585-590.
• [32] Kondo Shigeo, Takahashi Akifumi, Takizawa Kenji, Tokuhashi Kazuaki., Sekiya Akira. 2008. “A study on flammability limits of fuel mixtures”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 155 (3): 440-448
• [33] Zabetakis M.G., S. Lambiris, G.S. Scott. 1959. Flame temperatures of limit mixtures. In Proceedings of the 7th Symposium (International) on Combustion. Butterworths Scientific Publications. London: 484-487.
• [34] Sawicki Tomasz. 2005. „Wybuchy przestrzenne”. Bezpieczeństwo pracy: nauka i praktyka 11: 22-25.
• [35] Baranowski W. 1979. „Wybuchy przestrzenne mieszanin powietrzno- gazowych”. Problemy Kryminalistyki (38).
• [36] Ryng Marian. 1985. Bezpieczeństwo techniczne w przemyśle chemicznym – poradnik. Warszawa: WNT.
• [37] Mayer E. 1957. “Theory of flame propagation limits due to heat loss”. Combustion and Flame 1 (4): 438-452.
• [38] Vanderstraeten B., D. Tuerlinckx, J. Berghmans, S. Vliegen, E. Van’t Oost, B. Smit. 1997. „Experimental study of the pressure and temperature dependence on the upper flammability limit of methane/air mixtures”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 56 (3): 237-246.
• [39] Giurcan Venera, Domnina Razus, Maria Mitu, Dumitru Oancea. 2015. “Prediction of flammability limits of fuel-air and fuel-air-inert mixtures from explosivity parameters in closed vessels”. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 34: 65-71.
• [40] Razus Domnina, Codina Movileanu, Venera Brinzea, Dumitru Oancea. 2007. “Closed vessel combustion of propylene–air mixtures in the presence of exhaust gas”. Fuel 86: 1865-1872.
• [41] ASTM E681-09(2015). American Standard. Standard Test Method for Concentration Limits of Flammability of Chemicals (Vapors and Gases).
• [42] PN-EN 15967:2011. Polish-European Standard. Determination of maximum explosion pressure and the maximum rate of pressure rise of gases and vapours.
• [43] DIN 51649-1:1986-12. German Standard. Bestimmung der Explosionsgrenzen von Gasen und Gasgemischen in Luft.
• [44] PN-EN 14756:2008. Polish-European Standard. Determination of LOC for gases and vapours.
• [45] Gieras Marian, Rudolf Klemens, Piotr Wolański. 1986. “Experimental and theoretical study of ignition of single coal particles at zero gravity”. Acta Astronautica 13 (5): 231-239.
• [46] Jarosinski Józef, Jerzy Podfilipski, Andrzej Gorczakowski. 2002. „Experimental study of flame propagation in propane–air mixture near rich flammability limits in microgravity”. Combustion Science and Technology 174 (9): 21-48.
• [47] Furno A.L., E.B. Cook, J.M. Kuchta. 1971. “Some observations on near-limit flames”. Symposium (International) on Combustion 13 (1): 593-599.
• [48] Bradley Derek, Alan Mitcheson. 1976. “Mathematical Solutions for Explosions in Spherical Vessels”. Combustion and Flame 26 (2): 201-217.
• [49] Maria Molnarne, Peter Mizsey, Volkmar Schroder. 2005. “Flammability limits of gas mixtures, Part 2 – Influence of inert gases”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 121 (1-3): 45-49.
• [50] VDS 3527. German Standard. Guidelines for inerting and oxygen reduction systems.
• [51] EN/TR 15821. 2005. Guidance on inerting for the prevention of explosions. CEN.
• [52] Grabarczyk Marcin, Rafał Porowski, Andrzej Teodorczyk. 2013. „Stężeniowe granice wybuchowości par cieczy w podwyższonej temperaturze”. Scientific Conference of PhD Students and Young Scientists: Youth for Technology 2013. Płock. Poland.
• [53] Porowski Rafał, Wojciech Rudy, Andrzej Teodorczyk. 2012. „Analiza metod badawczych granic wybuchowości cieczy palnych”. Bezpieczeństwo i Technika Pożarnicza 28 (4): 63-70.
• [54] Porowski Rafał, Wojtek Rudy. 2011. „Przegląd badań w zakresie parametrów flash point i explosion point dla cieczy palnych”. Bezpieczeństwo i Technika Pożarnicza 23 (3): 41-54.
• [55] Pofit-Szczepańska Melania. 1971. Chemia palenia – obliczenia chemiczne w zastosowaniu pożarniczym. Warszawa: Wyd. Wyższa Oficerska Szkoła Pożarnicza.
• [56] Pilc Aleksander. 1955. „Zapobieganie wybuchom mieszanin palnych par i gazów z powietrzem – część I”. Przemysł chemiczny 38 (1).
• [57] Pilc Aleksander. 1955. „Niebezpieczeństwo wybuchów mieszanin palnych par i gazów z powietrzem – część II”. Przemysł chemiczny 38 (7).
• [58] Pilc Aleksander. 1955. „Niebezpieczeństwo wybuchów mieszanin palnych par i gazów z powietrzem – część III”. Przemysł chemiczny 38 (7).
• [59] Pilc Aleksander. 1956. „Niebezpieczeństwo wybuchów mieszanin palnych par i gazów z powietrzem – część IV”. Przemysł chemiczny 39 (8).
• [60] Pilc Aleksander. 1957. „Niebezpieczeństwo wybuchów mieszanin palnych par i gazów z powietrzem – część V”. Przemysł chemiczny 40 (10).
• [61] Bodhurtha P. Frank. 1980. Industrial explosion prevention and protection. Mc-Graw Hill. New York. USA.
• [62] Albahri A. Tareq. 2003. “Flammability characteristics of pure hydrocarbons”. Chemical Engineering Science 58 (16): 3629-3641.
• [63] Vidal M., W.J. Rogers, J.C. Holste, M.S. Mannan. 2004. “A review on estimation methods for flash points and flammability limits”. Process Safety Progress 23 (1): 47-55.
• [64] Baran Tadeusz, Aldona Polich. 2004. Wybuch i jego skutki – kryminalistyczne badania materiałów i urządzeń wybuchowych. Warszawa: Wyd. Centralnego Laboratorium Kryminalistycznego KGP.
• [65] Węsierski Tomasz. 2010. „Analiza właściwości palnych podstawowych grup związków organicznych”. Bezpieczeństwo i Technika Pożarnicza 19 (3): 83-98.
• [66] Gieras Marian, Rudolf Klemens, Allen Kuhl, Paweł Oleszczak, Waldemar Trzciński, Piotr Wolański. 2008. “Influence of the chamber volume on the upper explosion limit for hexane–air mixtures”. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 21 (4): 423-436.
• [67] Cashdollar L. Kenneth, Isaac A. Zlochower, Gregory M. Green, Richard A. Thomas, Martin Hertzber. 2000. “Flammability of methane, propane, and hydrogen gases”. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 13 (3-5): 327-340.
• [68] Jones J. Clifford. 1993. Combustion Science: Principles and Practice. Millenium Books. Newtown. Australia.
• [69] Hilado J. Carlos. 1975. “A method for estimating limits of flammability”. Journal of fire and flammability 6 (10-11): 130-139.
• [70] Pintar A.J. 1999. Predicting lower and upper flammability limits. In Proceedings on International Conference on Fire Safety 28.
• [71] Oehley E. 1953. „Ableitung empirischer gleichungen für die untere explosionsgrenze und den flammpunkt“. Chemie Ingenieur Technik 25 (7): 399-403.
• [72] White D., C.L. Beyler, C. Fulper, J. Leonard. 1997. “Flame spread on aviation fuels”. Fire Safety Journal 28 (1): 1-31.
• [73] Catoire Laurent, Valerie Naudet. 2005. “Estimation of temperature -dependent lower flammability limit of pure organic compounds in air at atmospheric pressure”. Process Safety Progress 24 (2): 130-137.
• [74] Jones J.C. 1998. “Reid vapor pressure as a route to calculating the flash points of petroleum fractions”. Journal of Fire Sciences 16 (3): 222-229.
• [75] Albahri A. Tareq. 2003. “Structural group contribution method for predicting the octane number of pure hydrocarbon liquids”. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research 42 (3): 657-662.
• [76] Benson W. Sidney, Jerry H. Buss. 1958. “Additivity rules for the estimation of molecular properties - thermodynamic properties”. Journal of Chemical Physics 29 (3): 546-572.
• [77] Cranium – Property Estimation Software. Molecular Knowledge Systems Inc. http://www.molknow.com
• [78] Poling E. Bruce, John M. Prausnitz, John P. O’Conell. 2001. The properties of gases and liquids. Mc-Graw Hill. New York.
• [79] http://www.aiche.org/dippr/events-products/801-database
• [80] Yong Pan, Jiang Juncheng, Wang Rui, Cao Hongyin, Cui Yi. 2009. “A novel QSPR model for prediction of lower flammability limits of organic compounds based on support vector machine”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 168 (2-3): 962-969.
• [81] Gharagheizi Farhad. 2009. “A QSPR model for estimation of lower flammability limit temperature of pure compounds based on molecular structure”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 169 (1-3): 217-220.
• [82] Gharagheizi Farhad. 2009. “Prediction of upper flammability limit percent of pure compounds from their molecular structures”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 167 (1-3): 507-510.
• [83] Gharagheizi Farhad, Poorandokht Ilani-Kashkouli, Amir H. Mohammadi. 2013. “Estimation of lower flammability limit temperature of chemical compounds using a corresponding state method”. Fuel 103: 899-904.
• [84] Mehdi Bagheri, Rajabi Mansoure, Mirbagheri Marziyeh, Amin Mohammad. 2012. “BPSO-MLR and ANFIS based modeling of lower flammability limit”. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 25 (2): 373-382.
• [85] Vidal M., W. Wong, W.J. Rogers, M.S. Mannan. 2006. “Evaluation of lower flammability limits of fuel–air–diluent mixtures using calculated adiabatic flame temperatures”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 130 (1-2): 21-27.
• [86] Zhou Minyong, Donald J.E. Gauthier. 1999. “A new method for adiabatic flame temperature estimations of hydrocarbon fuels”. Fuel 78 (4): 471-478.
• [87] Vidal M., W.J. Rogers, M.S. Mannan. 2006. “Prediction of Minimum Flash Point Behaviour for Binary Mixtures”. Process Safety and Environmental 84 (1): 1-9.
• [88] Dayhoff E. Judith. 1990. Neural Networks Principles. Prentice-Hall International. Upper Saddle River NJ. USA.
• [89] Khanna Tarun. 1990. Foundations of Neural Networks. Addison-Wesley Publishing Company. Boston. USA.
• [90] Kosiński Robert. 2002. Sztuczne sieci neuronowe – dynamika nieliniowa i chaos. Warszawa: WNT.
• [91] Osowski Stanisław. 2000. Sieci neuronowe do przetwarzania informacji. Warszawa: Oficyna Wydawnicza Politechniki Warszawskiej.
• [92] Rybarczyk Andrzej. 2008. Sztuczne sieci neuronowe – laboratorium (2nd revised edition). Poznań: Wydawnictwo Politechniki Poznańskiej.
• [93] Gharagheizi Farhad. 2009. “A new group contribution-based model for estimation of lower flammability limit of pure compounds”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 170 (2-3): 595-604.
• [94] Gharagheizi Farhad. 2011. “An accurate model for prediction of autoignition temperature of pure compounds”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 189 (1-2): 211-221.
• [95] Albahri A. Tareq. 2015. “MNLR and ANN structural group contribution methods for predicting the flash point temperature of pure compounds in the transportation fuels range”. Process Safety and Environmental Protection 93: 182-191.
• [96] Albahri A. Tareq. 2013. “Prediction of the lower flammability limit percent in air of pure compounds from their molecular structures”. Fire Safety Journal 59: 188-201.
• [97] Lazzus A. Juan. 2011. “Neural network/particle swarm method to predict flammability limits in air of organic compounds”. Thermochimica Acta 512 (1-2): 150-156.
• [98] Di Benedetto Almerinda. 2013. “The thermal/thermodynamic theory of flammability – The adiabatic flammability limits”. Chemical Engineering Science 99: 265-273.
• [99] Seaton H. William. 1991. “Group contribution method for predicting the lower and the upper flammable limits of vapors in air”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 27 (2): 169-185.
• [100] Le Chatelier Henri Louis, Octave Boudouard. 1898. “Limits of flammability of gaseous mixtures”. Bulletin de la Société Chimique de France (19).
• [101] Kondo Shigeo, Takizawa Kenji, Takahashi Akifumi, Tokuhashi Kazuaki. 2006. „Extended Le Chatelier’s formula for carbon dioxide dilution effect on flammability limits”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 138 (1-2): 1-8.
• [102] Kondo Shigeo, Takizawa Kenji, Takahashi Akifumi, Tokuhashi Kazuaki. 2006. “Extended Le Chatelier's formula and nitrogen dilution effect on the flammability limits”. Fire Safety Journal 41 (5): 406-417.
• [103] Yusuke Koshiba, Takashi Hasegawa, Bongchan Kim, Hideo Ohtani. 2017. “Flammability limits, explosion pressures, and applicability of Le Chatelier's rule to binary alkane–nitrous oxide mixtures”. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 45: 1-8.
• [104] Ma Tingguang. 2011. “A thermal theory for estimating the flammability limits of a mixture”. Fire Safety Journal 46 (8): 558-567.