Education management as an exact science (Russia, first half of the nineteenth century)

• Autorzy: Vishlenkova E.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.4467/0023589XKHNT.18.028.9519

• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

The author reveals an essence of bureaucratic knowledge by means of which the nature of educational management (of schools and universities) in the Russian Empire in the 1830s was changed. The article shows the difference between bureaucratic and scientific knowledge. The author proves that the organization of regular and universal data collection (in the form of reports and references) has created a system of collective responsibility, general employment, vertical circulation of information. At the same time, the content of the created knowledge did not infl uence the decisions of the Ministry of Public Education. Disciplinary and representative aspects of this practice - humility of professors and teachers participating in it, timely implementation of the instructions coming from above, the consistency shown in tables and the text of digital indicators were much more important for bureaucrats. Collected data were used by the Ministry to showcase the efficiency of control it exercised.

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Russian Empire; 19th century; history of education; bureaucratic knowledge; history of science

PL

Imperium Rosyjskie; XIX wiek; historia oświaty; biurokracja oświatowa; historia nauki

• Wydawca: Instytut Historii Nauki im. L. i A. Birkenmajerów Polskiej Akademii Nauk
• Czasopismo: Kwartalnik Historii Nauki i Techniki
• Rocznik: 2018
• Tom: R. 63, nr 4
• Strony: 93--114
• Opis fizyczny: Bibliogr. 74 poz.

Twórcy

autor

Vishlenkova E.

• National Research University - Higher School of Economics, Moscow

Bibliografia

• Literature
• Chibiryayev S.A., Velikii russkii reformator: Zhizn, deyatelnost, politicheskii vzglyadi M.M. Speranskogo, Moscow 1989.
• Ellis A., Golz R., Mayrhofer W., The Educational System of Germany and Other European Countries of the 19th Century in the View of American and Russian Classics: Horance Mann and Kostantin Ushinsky, “International Dialogues on Education: Past and Present” 2014, vol. 1, no 1.
• Haazer R., Ot bratstva po oruzhiyu k ideologicheskoy vrazhde: politizacia universitetskoi zhizni v Germanii i obraz Rossii v nacionalnom dvizhenii 1813-1819 godov, [in:] Istoria i istorisheskaya pamyat, ed. by A.V. Gladysheva, T.A. Bulygyna, vol. 6, Saratov, Stavropol 2012, p. 31-63.
• Good H., Tailer J.D., A History of Western Education. 3rd ed., London 1970.
• Ilina K.A., Arkhivi popechitelei uchebnih okrugov v Rossiiskoi imperii, [in:] Biographii universitetskih arkhivov, ed. by E.A. Vishlenkova, K.A. Ilina, V.S. Parsamov, Moscow 2017, p. 165-184.
• Khristoforov I.A., Sudba reformy: Russkoye krestiyanstvo v pravitelstvennoy politike do i posle otmeny krepostnogo prava (1830-1890), Moscow 2011.
• Kostina T.V., Kak universiteti Rossiyskoy imperii 20 let zhili po raznym zakonam, ili o poteryannom chinovnikami Ministerstva narodnogo prosvesheniya postanovlenii, “Sociologiya nauki i technologii” vol. 8, 2017, no 3, p. 50-55.
• Levinson K.A., Nekotoriye nabludeniya otnositelno yazika gosudarstvennogo deloproizvodstva v gorodah Svyashennoi Rimskoi imperii v Ranneye novoye vremya, “Arkheographicheskii yezhegodnik” 2006-2007, p. 124-146.
• Minakov A.Yu., Mikhail Leontiyevich Magnitskii, [in:] Protiv techeniya: istoricheskii portreti russkih konservatorov pervoi treti XIX veka, ed. by A.Y. Minakov, Voronezh 2005, p. 268-271.
• Nravstvenno-politicheskii otchet za 1839 god, [in:] “Rossiya pod nadzorom. Otcheti III otdeleniya 1827-1869”, ed. by M.V. Sidorova, E.I. Sherbakova, Moscow 2006.
• Popov O.V., S.S. Uvarov i podgotovka obshego ustava rossiyskih universitetov 1835 goda, [in:] “Rossiyskiye universiteti v XVIII-XX vekah”, vol. 4, Voronezh 1999, p. 18-28.
• Porter T., The Rise of Statistical Thinking, 1820-1900, Princeton 1986.
• Shepelev L.E., Chinovnii mir Rossii: XVIII - nachalo XX veka, Moscow 1999.
• Shetinina G.I., Posluzniye spiski kak istoricheskiy istochnik o sostave professorov v poreformennoy Rossii, [in:] Istoriya SSSR, 1977, no. 1, p. 84-96.
• Weber M., Khozyaistvo i obshestvo. Ocherki ponimayushey sociologii, vol. 1, Moscow 2016.
• Vishlenkova E.A., Ilina K.A., Nauka upravlyat’: gospodstvo cherez znanie i reforma upravleniya rossiiskim obrazovaniem v pervoi polovine XIX v., “Ab Imperio” 2017, no. 4. p. 65-108.
• Vishlenkova E.A., Ilina K.A., Ob uchenih stepenyah, i o tom, kak dissertacia v Rossii obretala prakticheskuyu i nauchuyu znachimost, “Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye” 2013, no. 4, p. 91.
• Vishlenkova E.A., Galiullina P.K., Ilina K.A., Russkiye professora, Moscow 2012.
• Printed sources
• Fortunatov F.N., Pamyatniye zametki vologzhanina, “Russkii arkhiv” vol. 12, 1867, p. 1646-1708.
• Instrukcia directoru Kazanskogo universiteta, 17th January 1820, “Sbornik postanovleniy po Minesterstvu narodnogo prosveshenia” vol. 1, 1864, no 374, stb. 1199-1220.
• Iz odesskih vospominanii Morozova, “Russkii arkhiv” vol. 3, 1877, p. 324-330.
• Lazhechnikov I.I., Kak ya znal M.L. Magnitskogo, “Russkii vestnik” vol. 61, 1866, p. 121-146.
• Magnitskii M.L., Kratkoye rukovodstvo k delovoy i gosudarstvennoy slovesnosti dlya chinovnikov, vstupayushih v sluzhbu, Moscow 1835.
• Matseevich L.S., Odesskie zametki o Magnitskom, “Russkii arkhiv” vol. 1, 1898, p. 223-230.
• Mikhail Leontiyevich Magnitsky. Noviye dannie k ego kharakteristike. 1829-1834, “Russkaya starina” vol. 11, 1875, p. 478-491.
• Morozov P.T., Moe znakomstvo s Magnitskim, “Russkii arkhiv” vol. 3, 1875, p. 241-250.
• O pozhertvovanii protoiyereem M. Pavlovskim knig dlya biblioteki duhovnoi seminarii. Prilagaetsa perechen knig, “Khersonskiye eparkhialniye vedomosti” vol. 14, 1874, p. 461-465.
• Ob uchrezhdenii komiteta dlya slicheniya i uravneniya ustavov uchebnih zavedenii i opredeleniya kursov ucheniya v onih, 14th May, 1826, “Sbornik postanovlenii po Ministerstvu narodnogo prosvesheniya” vol. 10, 1864, stb. 22.
• Pisma raznih lits Ivanu Ivanovichu Dmitrievu, “Russkii arkhiv”, 1866, p. 1710-1711.
• Rozhdestvenskii S.V., Istoricheskii obzor deyatelnosti Ministerstva narodnogo prosvesheniya: 1802-1902, Saint-Petersburg 1902.
• Sobstvennoruchnoye vsepoddaneisheye pismo deistvitelnogo tainogo sovetnika Magnitskogo, s podneseniyem zapiski o narodnom vospitanii, [in:] Sbornik istoricheskih materialov, izvlechennih iz arkhiva I-go Otdeleniya S.E.I.V. Kantselyarii, Saint-Petersburg 1876, vol. 1, p. 363.
• Sturdza A.S., Vospominaniya o Mikhaile Leontiyeviche Magnitsom, “Russkii arkhiv” 1868, p. 926-938.
• Tsirculyarnoye predlozheniye o svoyevremennom predstavlenii formulyarnih spiskov i svedeniy o peremenah chinovnikov, 21st December, 1834, “Sbornik rasporyazheniy po Ministerstvu narodnogo prosvesheniya” vol. 1, 1866, no. 510, stb. 985-987.
• Uvarov S.S., Desiyatiletiye Ministerstva narodnogo prosvesheniya, 1833-1843, Saint-Petersburg 1864.
• Uvarov S.S., Iz zapiski “O sredstvah sdelat narodnoye vospitaniye specialnym, ne otstupaiya ot obshih vidov onogo”, [in:] Universitetskaya ideya v Rossiyskoi imperii XVIII - nachala XX vekov: antologiya, Moscow 2011.
• Vospominaniya V.I. Panaeva, “Vestnik Evropi” vol. 4, 1867, p. 72-121.
• Voyeikov A.F., Dom sumasshedshih, Moscow 1911.
• Vyazemsky P.A., Iz staroi zapisnoi knizhki, “Russkii arkhiv” vol. 1, 1874, p. 173-202.
• Zagoskin N.N., Istoriya imperatorskogo Kazanskogo universiteta za sto let ego sushestvovaniya. 1804-1904, vol. 1, Vvedenie i chast pervaya. 1804-1814, Kazan 1902.
• Zapiski, izdavayemiye ot Departamenta narodnogo prosvesheniya vol. 2, 1827, p. 7.
• Archival sources
• National Archive of the Republic of Tatarstan (Nacionalniy arkhiv Respubliki Tatarstan, Kazan) [NART], f. 92, op. 1, d. 599, Zhurnal iskhodyashikh bumag za 1819 god, p. 72r.
• NART, f. 92, op. 1, d. 2393, Delo o dostavlenii prikhodno-rskhodnikh knig kantselyarii popechitelya Kazanskogo uchebnogo okruga v komissiyu, visochaishe uchrezdennuyu dlya obrevizovanii schetov Kazanskogo universiteta, 1827, p. 13-14.
• NART, f. 92, op. 1, d. 3823, Formi godichnogo otcheta po universitetam i uchebnim okrugam, 1833-1835, p. 1-131.
• Department of Rare Books and Manuscripts of N.I. Lobachevsky Scientific Library in Kazan Federal University (Otdel redkih rukopisey i knig Nauchnoy biblioteki imeni N.I. Lobachevskogo Kazanskogo Federalnogo Universiteta, Kazan) [ORRK NBL KFU], No 7831, Pis’mo popechitelya M.L. Magnitskogo rektoru G.B. Nikol’skomu, 21 marta 1822 goda, p. 10-10r.
• Manuscript Division of the Russian National Library (Otdel rukopisey Rossiyskoy nationalnoy biblioteki, St.-Petersburg) [OR RNB], f. 531, no. 390, p. 2r-3.
• Russian State Historical Archive (Rossiyskiy gosudarstvenniy istoricheskiy arkhiv, St.-Petersburg) [RGIA], f. 733, Departament narodnogo prosvesheniya», op. 40, d. 116
• «Zapiska, sostavlennaya departamentom narodnogo prosvesheniya po delu profesora M.A. Pal’mina, 1828, p. 204r.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 40, d. 205, Prilozhenie k delu o revizii Kazanskogo universiteta i gimnazii general-maiotom P.F. Zheltukhinim, 1826, p. 13.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 39, d. 354, Delo o predostavlenii otcheta o sostoyanii Kazanskogo Universiteta, 1821, p. 6r.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 39, d. 354, Delo o predostavlenii otcheta o sostoyanii Kazanskogo Universiteta, 1821, p. 7.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 787, Otchet Imperatorskogo Khar’kovskogo Universiteta za 1857 god, p. 149.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 195, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1835, p. 25.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 528, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1838, p. 109.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 226, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1849, p. 3.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 226, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1849, p. 22r, 29r, 33.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 237, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1855, p. 27r.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 522, Otchet po Imperatorskomu Moskovskomu univeritetu, 1837, p. 50.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 226, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1849, p. 38r.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 587, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1847, p. 4r.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 612, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1853, p. 4-7r.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 95, d. 237, Otchet Imperatorskogo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1855, p. 2.
• RGIA, f. 733, op. 47, d. 74, Dela po khodataistvu popechitelya Kazanskogo uchebnogo okruga o prinyatii mer k uluchsheniyu sostoyaniya Kazanskogo universiteta v svyazi s otlivom iz nego professorov v stolichnie universiteti, 1856, p. 1-2.
• RGIA, f. 745, op. 1, d. 107, Raporti nachal’nika arkhiva V. Petrova o sostoyanii archiwa I proizvedennikh v nem rabotakh, perepiska s Departamentom narodnogo prosvesheniya o navedenii spravok i prieme del, 1830, p. 69r-70.
• RGIA, f. 1290, op. 1, d. 135, Zapiska general-maiora Liprandi o politicheskoi statistike, 1840.
• RGIA, f. 1290, op. 1, d. 141, Otnoshenie upravlyayushego Vremennogo statisticheskogo komiteta dlya sostavleniya programmi i instruktsii dlya statisticheskogo opisaniya Rossii s prilozheniem zapiski Leksa ‘Glavnie osnovaniya dlya otechestvennoi statistiki, predprinimaemoi v MVD’, 1843.
• Central State Archive of Moscow (Tsentralniy gosudarstvenniy archiv Moskvy, Moscow)
• [TsGAM], f. 418, op. 2, d. 234, Formi dlya sostavleniya ezhegodnogo otcheta po universitetu i Moskovskomu uchebnomu okrugu, 1833, p. 1-157.
• TsGAM, f. 459, op. 2, d. 1741, O sokrashenii deloproizvodstva I ob otmene predstavleniya nekotorikh srochnikh svedenii i donesenii, 1851-1853, p. 52-52r.
• TsGAM, f. 459, op. 2, d. 835, p. 13-17.
• TsGAM, f. 459, op. 2, d. 777, p. 1r.
• TsGAM, f. 459, op. 2, d. 1741, O sokrashenii deloproizvodstva i ob otmene predstavleniya nekotorikh srochnikh svedenii i donesenii, 1851-1853, p. 52-52r.

Uwagi

Opracowanie rekordu w ramach umowy 509/P-DUN/2018 ze środków MNiSW przeznaczonych na działalność upowszechniającą naukę (2019).