The extent to which the interests of third parties are respected in proceedings for the demolition of a structure

• Autorzy: Smarż Joanna
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

The obligation to respect the interests of third parties is one of the conditions that should be fulfilled in the construction process. However, the extent of this respect is somewhat different during the planning and implementation of the project and somewhat different during the demolition phase of the construction work. At this final stage of the existence of a construction object, the interests of third parties will not be protected to the same extent as in the case of its creation, i.e. when a building permit is obtained. However, this does not mean that these interests can be disregarded.

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Building Act; construction process; interests of third parties; protection of interests; demolition; demolition permit; impact area

• Wydawca: Oficyna Wydawnicza POLCEN Sp. z o.o. ; Ośrodek Informacji "Technika instalacyjna w budownictwie''
• Czasopismo: Budownictwo i Prawo
• Rocznik: 2024
• Tom: R. 27, nr 1
• Strony: 10--12
• Opis fizyczny: Bibliogr. 21 poz.

Twórcy

autor

Smarż Joanna

• Department of Administrative Law and Administration Science, Faculty of Law and Administration, K. Pułaski University, Radom

• https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2450-8162

Bibliografia

• [1] Journal of Laws 2023, item 682, as amended.
• [2] Hauser R., Niewiadomski Z., Constitutional aspects of regulating the investment and construction process. State and Law 2015, 6: 3.
• [3] Verdict of the TK of 12.01.2000, P 11/98, Legalis no. 46357.
• [4] Hauser R., Niewiadomski Z., Constitutional aspects of the regulation of the investment and construction process, Rzeczpospolita 2015, 6: 4.
• [5] Act of 27 March 2003 amending the Act - Construction Law and amending certain acts (Journal of Laws 2003, No. 80, item 718).
• [6] Smarż J., Respecting the legitimate interests of third parties in the construction process, Law and Bond 2020: 141-156.
• [7] Verdicts of the WSA of 24.01.2018, II SA/Gd 572/17. Legalis no. 1721467.
• [8] Verdicts of the WSA: of 15.11.2017. IV SA/Po 774/17, Legalis no 1693421: of 6.09.2015, Il SA/Łd 568/15, Legalis no 1387915; and of 8.08.2017, II SA/Łd 469/17, Legalis no 1653706.
• [9] Radziszewski E., Construction Law. Provisions and commentary. Warsaw 2006: 28.
• [10] Niewiadomski Z., Construction Law. Commentary, Legalis 2018, commentary to Article 5 of the Construction Law.
• [11] Kosicki A., The concept of „respecting the legitimate interests of third parties” in construction law. Real Estate 2007. 8.
• [12] Kostka Z., Construction Law. Commentary. Gdańsk 2007: 32-33.
• [13] Szwajdler W., Evolution of the protection of third party rights in the construction process [in:] Jubilee book of prof. Stanisław Jędrzejewski, [ed.] Nowicki H., Szwajdler W., Toruń 2009: 491-493.
• [14] Ostrowska A., Construction permit, Warsaw 2009: 272.
• [15] Verdict of the WSA in Łódź of 23.06.2022. II SA/Łd 844/21, Legalis no. 2768744.
• [16] Wyrok WSA w Kielcach z 20.06.2018 r., II SA/Ke 328/18, Legalis no 1818570.
• [17] Verdict of the NSA of 29.05.2013. II OSK 285/12, Legalis no. 1200976 and judgment of the WSA in Warsaw of 4.12.2015. Vll SA/Wa 2506/14. Legalis no. 1383110.
• [18] Verdict of the WSA in Warsaw of 28.02.2018. VII SA/Wa 1141/17. Legalis no. 1742481.
• [19] Verdict of the WSA of 19.12.2019, II OSK 3249/18, Legalis no. 2284212.
• [20] Journal of Laws of 2020, item 471.
• [21] Kosicki A., Protection of third parties' interests in Polish construction law. Doctoral dissertation, Białystok 2021: 69, https://repozytorium.uwb.edu.pl/jspui/bitstream/11320/12555/1/A_Kosicki_Ochrona_interesow_osob_trzecich_w_polskim_prawie_budowlanym.pdf [accessed 3 January 2024].